Fairness for all our schools?

The South Wales Echo http://bit.ly/c5h11y is today reporting that Cardiff Council expect to resolve the problem of school places in Canton by building a new Welsh medium primary school.

I know that many people in that area will be delighted that those in the Welsh medium sector will get this investment; for many years the expansion of this sector has been based on taking over existing buildings that had been occupied by English medium schools. I admit that this isn’t the best way to provide the additional capacity.

In fact the construction of a new Welsh medium school is exactly what I and our Councillors in Whitchurch argued for there.

The Council’s original proposals for Canton are very similar to those published for Whitchurch, effectively a decrease in pupil places in English medium with an expansion to cope with demand in the Welsh medium sector. Our view was ignored by the Council who maintained that the options they published were the best, claiming that they couldn’t provide for an expansion to Welsh medium places without dealing with the “problem of surplus places” in the English schools.

The Council’s intention is to give Canton what we argued for in Whitchurch. I have always maintained that Whitchurch benefits from having excellent schools regardless of which language the children are taught. We have seen our community turn in on itself, fuelled by a Council so insensitive that it couldn’t see the pitfalls of designing the reorganisation in this way.

If the children in Canton can benefit from this investment, which I welcome, then so should the children in Whitchurch.

2 Responses to “Fairness for all our schools?”

  1. Geoff Says:

    Now there’s a funny thing. Whitchurch came up with this solution, rejected by the Council and now the solution is being applied in Canton.

    Any chance that Berman will do an about face now in Whitchurch? The wait is torturous.

  2. Jonathan Morgan AM Says:

    My response to Geoff is that I doubt it! The Council leadership is committed to reducing the provision of education in Whitchurch and placing the Welsh medium school in a building which they don’t want. I think Berman is happy to wait for the verdict of the Assembly Government. It does appear as though there’s one rule for one part of Cardiff and a different rule for Whitchurch